I went to see Watchmen finally at the IMAX in the Trop. It's very easy to slip into some pseudo-intellectual term paper mode after seeing it, but everyone will have their opinion. Mine? I was a fan of the comic book and I dug the movie a lot.
Here's a screenshot of Rorschach getting close to Bigger Figure in the jail. Jackie Earle Hailey killed it as the man in the mask and his scenes in jail were probably the high points of the movie for me.